How Democrats try to portray the republican lies about health care of immigrants who are not documented The US federal government closed 2025
toAfter the government closed on Wednesday, Republicans in Congress and Donald Trump repeated misleading allegations that the Democrats were trying to pass a decision that would provide “free health care to illegal fighters.” It has become a good refusal to fuel legislators from the Republican Party as government financing has passed this week.
In the White House on Wednesday, Vice President JD Vance said that the Democratic spending plan “would be retracted” from the work of the beautiful draft law (OBBA)-which End Among many types of current immigrants to access health coverage from the federal government, such as Medicaid, Medicare, and Medicare Care (ACA) subsidies for private health insurance.
Meanwhile, the Republican Command in the Capitol Hill maintained its colleagues across the corridor, while maintaining the government “hostility”, while fencing financing bills continue to fail in the Senate.
“They made a decision to prefer to give them the advantages of taxpayers to illegal foreigners, instead of keeping the doors open to the American people,” Mike Johnson, Speaker of the Republican Parliament, told a press conference on Thursday.
Democrats have criticized Republican allegations.
“The only federal dollar does not go to providing healthy insurance for illegal immigrants. No. One. Benny,” He said Senate’s largest democracy, Chuck Schumer. “Republicans prefer lying and closing the government rather than protecting your health care.”
in interview With ABC News, on the first day of the government’s closure, the leader of the minority in the House of Representatives, Hakim Jeffrez, Republican claims. “The federal law prohibits the use of medical care, the children’s health insurance program and the law of care at reasonable prices to provide health insurance in any way, shape or shape, for uncomfortable immigrants.” Democrats are not trying to change this. “
By framing the case as related to illegal immigration, it turns the debate to the land that is “friendly” politically of the Republican Party, according to Jonathan Oberland, professor of health care policy at North Carolina University in Chapel Hill.
“[Republicans] “Do not want to talk about health care provisions, while Democrats, in general, do not want to talk a lot about immigration. They want to talk a lot about health care and loss of health insurance, and this is exactly what they do,” Oberland Ander said.
Unconvinced immigrants are still not qualified for the federal government’s health insurance, and they can only receive emergency emergency treatment, according to long American laws. Instead, correcting the financing of Democrats seeks to reflect many discounts to Medicaid, which is scheduled to enter into force after the Trump local agenda has passed earlier this year.
This includes allowing non -attending citizens – which includes several groups, such as refugees and asylum seekers, and those who have a temporary reserve case (TPS), and survivors of home abuse and human trafficking who are waiting for visas or documents – are still registered in some federal health care programs. All these immigrants have entered the country legally and are calculated by the federal government.
The CBO budget office estimates that the OBBA effect will leave about 1.4 million non -citizen without coverage.
Uberland says that the dilemma in Washington continues, it seems that none of these differences appears to be incapable. He added: “These are all groups that can lead to political sympathy, but I am not sure that they can penetrate the wrong information, the toxic environment and the restricted age in which we live now.”
“I think what they are [Democrats] They will do, and what they do, is simply to say that this has nothing to do with immigrants who are not documented. This is not about them. You take health insurance away from the Americans. “
According to Michael Trugilo, a veteran democratic strategic expert, Republicans were able to land in their messages about the government’s closure by playing “attack”, mainly because the language of preserving Democrats is difficult to sell.
“What we are trying to do is to keep what people have today,” Trujio said.
Trujillo indicated that Democrats should also “repeat the lie” to dismantle the premature allegations of Republicans and Hazafin that their financing bill will provide health care for illegal immigrants.
“If they are [Republicans’] The discussion, we accuse you of admiration of sour milk. Then we replied, “We are actually do not like sour milk.” Well, guess, lean milk has just become the issue. “
This week, Caroline Levit said programs like TPS is “a complete abuse of the immigration system” that allows “applicants from all over the world to obtain free benefits” while speaking to journalists. Since his return to office, Trump has tried to end the temporary protection of several countries through a series of lawsuits of varying degrees of success.
It is worth noting that the White House press secretary was not clear when answering a question from one of the correspondents, who asked whether doctors should treat patients in the emergency rooms regardless of their migration condition – which is required under Federal Law. “I am not talking about the emergency rooms throughout the country, I am talking about the President of the United States,” she replied.
Through their ongoing decision, Democrats also try to address the cuts in OBBA to medical dollars hospitals from the federal government – due to the emergency care that is given to provide it to individuals who have no qualified migration, but they were eligible for medical aid. According to a recent analysis conducted by KFF, this type of emergency spending was calculated For less than 1 % Of the total expenditures of the program between 2017-2023.
Larry Levitt, Executive Vice President of Health Policy at KFF, said that the wrong claim about who is getting health care was “the biggest effort in wrong information in the issue of health policy since Republicans claimed that the sponsorship law at reasonable prices included” deaths. “
He said: “I am sure it is an effective discussion point to say that the Democrats want to expand health care of illegal immigrants, but this is not true.”
One of the main aspects of the Democratic Financing Law, one of whom confirmed more than the reflection of the discounts in the Republican Budget Law, is a permanent extension of the widespread tax credits ACA, which is scheduled to end at the end of this year. KFF is able to healthcare costs It was seized on a double For the vast majority of registered when these benefits decrease. Meanwhile, the Central Bank of Oman expected that about 4 million people would lose their health insurance if the reinforced tax credits are expired at the end of 2025.
“My feeling is that they are [Democratic leadership] “He will take a deal if only subsidies will be extended,” said Uberlander. As Uberland said. He emphasized that pushing the Democrats to reverse the broader health care discounts in the comprehensive tax legislation of the president may be more than that of the request: “They do not want to pay attention to the fact that the Republicans have gone on and what are the effects, but they know, in real, there is no opportunity to save them.